The "Dark Shadow" has a long history of haunting the Lodge with first-hand accounts dating back to at least the 1980s and continuing to this day. Here's a list of the most significant sightings to date:
- A tenant on the second floor awakened early in the morning and witnessed a dark form sitting at the end of her bed.
- Standing at a hallway desk, a hostess watched as a dark, misty form floated down the main staircase into the old barroom.
- Alone in the Douglass Room about 10:00 pm, a worker witnessed a dark form cross over the hallway to the basement steps.
- A visitor alone in the old bar room saw a dark form enter from the main hallway and disappear.
- A paranormal investigation team filmed a pitch-black form in the second floor front bedroom. On the video, the entity is well-formed and not transparent.